Skip to content
November 9, 2026
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism
  • Capital and crisis
  • Capital and domestic work !
  • Capital and exploitation of children
  • Struggle against oppression and gender discrimination
  • Capitalism and forcible poverty
  • Against environmental degradation and destruction of nature !
  • Lesson and achievements of the world labour movement
  • Views and reviews
  • The class battle against exploitation and plunder of products of labor
  • workersagainstagainstwagelaboursystem

Primary Menu
  • Home
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour
  • Capital and crisis
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism
  • Capital and the child labor
  • Capital and domestic work
  • Against environmental degradation and destruction of nature
  • Struggle against oppression and gender discrimination
  • Capitalism and forcible poverty
  • Lesson and achievements of the world labour movement
  • Views and reviews
Live
  • Home
  • 2026
  • October
  • 16
  • Davoud Razavi and the Struggle in the Arena!
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism

Davoud Razavi and the Struggle in the Arena!

u1 October 16, 2026 30 min read

Nasser Paydar  Part Ten of  Right-wing unionist reformism

Davoud Razavi, a board member of the Vahed Company Syndicate, has recently authored an article. In this piece steeped in unbridled rage and malice he lashes out at any talk of struggle against capital and condemns any action that runs counter to the survival of capitalism. Weaving together a hodgepodge of pro-capitalist rhetoric tailored to the tastes of his ideological cohorts, he presents degenerate, reformist syndicalism as the sole saviour of the Iranian working masses. In truth, Razavi’s arguments require no critique; each of his statements serves as a vivid, damning indictment of the very brand of syndicalism he and his ilk champion a movement through which they have taken it upon themselves to deceive the workers and bury the anti-capitalist struggle of the Iranian working class. Nevertheless, the points raised in his text offer a valuable opportunity to further dissect syndicalism examining its strategic role in fortifying the foundations of capitalist power and stifling any radical, anti-capitalist stirrings among the working masses.

Davoud Razavi writes: “In a society where millions of people are seeking to sell their labour power but cannot find a buyer, it is unclear how you intend to abolish the wage system. What is the meaning of such talk in a society where people are forced to hold two or three jobs just to get by? Instead of directing us toward entities like his ‘Organization for the Abolition of Wage Labour’ leaving one to wonder whether the people meant to implement it would have to arrive in Iran from Mars why don’t you start with the resources actually at hand? Why won’t you acknowledge that practical, on-the-groundwork is difficult and costly and that neither you nor your associates are capable of carrying it out? Aiming for the impossible is a sure sign that nothing will be achieved.”

Razavi whispers into the ears of the Iranian working masses all the anti-labour superstitions and delusions concocted by the most reactionary ideological representatives of the capitalist system. The gist of his argument is that the actual problem facing the Iranian working masses is merely a shortage of buyers for their labour power. In other words, the Iranian working class has no issue whatsoever with the very relationship of buying and selling labour power! Their fundamental predicament, according to him, is simply that there are not enough “customers” to purchase their labour power. Hunger, poverty, destitution, prostitution, addiction, and the wretched misery afflicting tens of millions of Iranian workers and their families have nothing to do with the capitalist system; nor does the struggle against these conditions depend on a struggle against capitalism itself. All these calamities and misfortunes exist solely because workers are unable to sell their labour power; the root of these problems is not wage-labour itself, but rather the absence of “customers” to exploit these wage slaves and purchase their virtually free labour power. Davoud Razavi, for his part, feels no need for any degree of coherence in the arguments he cobbles together. Immediately after making this claim in the very next sentence, following directly upon the first he adds that in this society, every worker is compelled to hold three jobs just to make a living, selling their labour power across three shifts every single day. This trade union activist from the Vahed Company never pauses to ask himself why two consecutive, linked statements of his could be so utterly contradictory. Why is it that, within this dark, man-killing hell known as capitalism, a worker must toil three shifts a day merely to secure bread for their children and sustain a wretched existence defined by humiliation and deprivation while, across the length and breadth of this same worker-devouring hell, 10 million people remain unemployed, and a vast number of women from that same class are driven into prostitution by the desperate hunger of their own children? It would take a modicum of coherent, anti-capitalist, working-class consciousness to navigate the twists and turns of these glaring, unruly contradictions and probe their root causes. Why does everyone have to work, work in several places and work several shifts in a row, but 10 million people are hot slaves of unemployed wages, burn on their faces in the flames of death, hunger, deprivation and humiliation and become ashes. From the cultural arsenal of syndicalism, Daud Razavi generously pulls out all the oiled weapons of obscenity one after the other and aims at every anti-wage slave breather. Intoxicated by playing the role of peshmerga for capital, he shouts that the problem of workers is not wage labour but the lack of buyers of wage labour, but he does not even ask himself for a moment where what he calls the “lack of buyers of labour” or the unemployment of workers came from and from which womb the evil germ of the social order was born. Why was there no buyer of labour and why unemployment? These are the fetid phenomena and offspring of which social system? During the last 20 years, only the volume of foreign investments in the world has increased 30 times. During this same period, the number of unemployed workers worldwide has multiplied. If the plight of the Iranian worker or any worker elsewhere in the world is not, in fact, the system of wage slavery; if the catastrophic existence of this vast mass of the “cursed” buried alive in this existing hell is merely due to a “lack of buyers for labour power,” then why is it that all this investment, this massive accumulation of capital, and the ever-increasing saturation of the globe with fresh, additional capital have not only failed to alleviate the problem of unemployment, but have, in fact, made the prospect of selling one’s labour power increasingly and progressively more remote? Within the dark, hellish reality of capitalism in Iran, between the years 2005 and 2008 (1384–1387) according to official government sources more than 25.455 billion US dollars were added to the existing stock of accumulated capital. During these same years, the number of unemployed individuals also rose by at least two million. Let us once again examine the unfolding record of capital investment. Over the past two years, well over a million unemployed individuals have been added to the vast army of the jobless in Iranian society; approximately 200 medium-to-large factories have dismissed their workers, casting their families’ wives and children into a wasteland of hunger. The primary excuses cited by the owners of these production facilities have been either foreign sanctions or a “shortage of liquidity.” But during this very period of intensifying sanctions, the volume of foreign capital invested in Iran’s domestic market has surged by 70%, and the liquidity held by the private sector has climbed from 31 trillion tomans to 164 trillion tomans. Davoud Razavi buries his head in the snow like a partridge to avoid witnessing the catastrophe of that sinister Specter known as the capitalist system: the root of all evil in this era and on this earth, and the source of all the miseries endured by the billions of workers across the globe. With utter shamelessness, he denies its very existence. He asks: “When everyone is suffering and lamenting the ‘absence of buyers for labour power,’ what is this talk about opposing the wage-labour system?” The appalling stupidity of the syndicalist mindset so locks the human mind and blinds the eyes that even the simplest, most self-evident realities of life are perceived in a completely inverted manner, rendering one utterly incapable of grasping the truth. Were it otherwise and had he the capacity to observe his surroundings with even a modicum of working-class insight he would realize that the catastrophic unemployment affecting tens of millions of workers is rooted not in the fluctuation in the number of those who purchase labour power, but in the very nature of the relationship defined by the buying and selling of labour power. To grasp this truth, Davoud Razavi requires no academic training, nor does he need to sit at the feet of any economist. He need only cast a glance at the conditions of labour, exploitation, and the social existence of tens of millions of Iranian workers, and ask himself: Why, in fact, are more than 10 million workers unemployed? Why is it that as the mountain of accumulated capital grows ever higher piercing the very heavens the ranks of the unemployed continue to swell? Why, despite the ceaseless, ongoing expansion of investment, do hundreds of factories shut down, leaving their workers dismissed? And why, alongside the monstrous, frenzied growth of capital investment across all economic sectors, do the real wages of the employed workforce continue to shrink day by day, becoming increasingly negligible? Why did the Iran National factory in the 1950s employ about 8,000 workers with a capital of 10 million tomans, and the current Iran Khodro, with more than 1,000 times the capital of those days, does not even employ 3 times the number of workers that day? Why does the working class of Iran during the last decade, despite the rule of one of the most brutal and predatory dictatorships in the capital world, continuously raise its wage level with the pressure of class struggle, and why now, in the era of the domination of another of the most cruel, criminal and heinous dictatorships of capital, despite much wider and more planned campaigns, it does not even receive its salaries 6 months to 6 months. Daud Razavi can ask himself why, in addition to the existence of more than 10 million unemployed job seekers, second by second, the intensity of work, the speed of work, the difficulty of work and all other aspects of the unrestrained escalation of the exploitation of the working masses of the working class are increasing? Why, along with the constantly rising curve of the volume of surplus values, according to the explicit admission of the Supreme Labor Council of the Islamic State, 70% of the workers work with a monthly salary of less than one hundred thousand tomans? Why is the full employment of the second half of the 1950s replaced by 30% unemployment today, and in parallel, the 300% surplus value rate of those years is replaced by a 1200% surplus value rate in today’s terms?

Instead of remaining frozen and ossified within the banal formulation of an “absence of buyers for labour power,” Davoud Razavi could have reflected on the phenomenon of unemployment. He could have investigated the root of this catastrophe which afflicts a vast segment of the working class in Iran and globally to discover that the foundation of all the miseries endured by the world’s working masses lies in the very existence of the wage-labour relationship. As long as this degenerate, worker-destroying relationship dominates society and the world, unemployment or what he terms an “absence of buyers for labour power” will remain an inevitable, insoluble, and ever-growing, escalating reality. Had this member of the Vahed Company Syndicate possessed the capacity for such reflection and had he not blinded himself with the “kohl” of capital he would never have dared to state, with such utter shamelessness, that the problem facing the Iranian worker is merely an “absence of buyers for labour power.” “Opposition to wage labour what kind of talk is that?”!!

Mr. Razavi lacks this capacity and ability precisely because he is a syndicalist. Here, it is both fitting and necessary to re-emphasize a crucial point regarding the class struggle. Contrary to the common view held by various sects and pseudo-leftist parties, the reason this member of the Vahed Company Syndicate has ended up in such a state is not due to his being “stuck” within the realm of a worker’s spontaneous reaction to capital, nor is it a lack of formal, ideological, or doctrinal training. Rather, it is the result of his deliberate, conscious choice to wallow in the quagmire of reformism and syndicalism. What Razavi articulates is, word for word, the inner sentiment of the entire trade union movement and right-wing, syndicalist reformism across the globe. Throughout its entire history, this approach has by means of these very incantations, prayers, and fabrications consigned the global labour movement to the gallows of wage slavery. Everywhere, it has instilled in workers the notion that the root of existing poverty, misery, unemployment, and disenfranchisement does not lie in the fundamental nature of the capitalist system or the existence of the wage-labour relationship; rather, it supposedly lies in the specific planning of the capitalist order of production and politics implying that mere adjustments to this order could serve as a panacea for all human suffering and the plight of the working masses. In this regard, trade union reformism has played a monumental role in perpetuating capitalism and keeping humanity trapped in the depths of the quagmire of wage slavery a role it continues to play with ever-increasing intensity, and in a manner far more malicious and sordid than ever before.

Davoud Razavi, a trade union activist and board member of the Vahed Company Syndicate, continues: “What kind of ‘anti-capitalist organization’ is this, in a country that has claimed to be anti-capitalist for thirty years? The Vahed Syndicate has at the very least, been in conflict with the government and the municipality the employers over the past few years. Why don’t you target even one specific faction of the capitalist class in Iran never mind the entire system?” Following the very tradition of his predecessors and the archaic roots from which his own approach stems, Davoud Razavi presents one of the most vicious, fearsome, and predatory capitalist states of our time to the working masses as an “anti-capitalist” government! One might argue that he does not personally hold this view but is merely relaying the state’s own claim. Let us assume that is the case! Even then, a serious question arises: why should the mere existence of such a claim or the anti-labour ruses and demagoguery employed by this dark, cancerous manifestation of capital be treated as a concrete material basis, an ironclad proof that an anti-capitalist struggle (or any discourse challenging the wage-labour system) is irrelevant and unnecessary? Does this not scream, with absolute clarity, that he is not merely recounting the claims of a predatory capitalist state, but is, in fact, expressing his own genuine belief? If someone does not actually believe the claims of a regime claims that are thoroughly criminal, deceitful, and murderous toward the working class why then do they make these very claims the material basis for their own approach and the foundation of their reasoning for every political or labour-related activity they undertake? It is crystal clear that, deep down, this person accepts one of the most bloodthirsty and fearsome capitalist states of our time as an anti-capitalist regime and is determined to portray it as such to workers who much like the individual in question are labouring under illusions. In short, their argument is that the dominant political power in Iran is an anti-capitalist state! According to this view, the problem facing society is not the existence of capitalism or the fact that the ruling power upholds this system; rather, the problem is merely a shortage of buyers for labour power. Building upon this line of reasoning, Razavi with a staggering degree of stupidity asks: in such a society, why should there be any talk of struggling against capitalism or opposing wage labour?! In this context, it is worth noting that the very idea of ​​an Iranian worker believing that a rabidly capitalist state is “anti-capitalist” is, naturally, implausible. One might well ask: is it even possible for a worker in Iranian society to entertain such a disastrous notion? Our answer is: yes, this has occurred, and perhaps it still does. After all, for years on end, anti-labour parties aligned with the Soviet bloc such as the Tudeh Party and the Fadda’s (Majority) faction spun such malicious nonsense and peddled it to the working class! Even today, figures like Davoud Razavi are capable of repackaging those same ideas and presenting them to the masses of workers. Beyond this, another question arises for the ardent defender of “right-wing” Iranian syndicalism: suppose the capitalist state of Iran or any other state was to employ the most absurd conspiracy theories to portray itself as “anti-capitalist,” “anti-imperialist,” or even a “workers’ state”!!! From where and from the altar of which capitalist deity did Davoud Razavi derive this repulsive, superstitious dogma, which suggests that under such conditions and in the face of such dark, anti-labour demagoguery workers should abandon their anti-capitalist struggle and refrain from voicing any critique of the wage-labour system?  Who or which clique, in league with the most rabid, murderous rulers of capital taught the workers (whether in the former Soviet bloc, or in present-day China, Vietnam, North Korea, Cuba, Bolivia, and Venezuela) that they should abandon the struggle against capital the fight to abolish the system of wage slavery simply because their rulers engage in empty, boisterous rhetoric against capitalism? Are they supposed to consign this struggle to the dustbin of history?! A board member of the “Vahed” (United Bus Company) Syndicate continues to air his views, stating: “…It is common knowledge that if workers enjoy decent work, job security, and a life befitting a human being if they work to live, rather than living to work and if their representatives are elected from the grassroots, free from pressure or interference by the state or employers, then these genuine representatives will secure favourable conditions for the workers through collective bargaining and the defence of their rights. Consequently, workers would have no reason to feel apathetic toward their jobs or to withhold their full commitment. If satisfied, a worker performs better, knowing that their individual well-being contributes to the well-being of society as a whole. Productivity naturally rises. This is only possible through the establishment of independent labour unions and organizations, and this is no mere illusion.” Every single point in these assertions constitutes demagoguery and the propagation of a debilitating illusion, aimed at the working masses of Iran. Furthermore, these statements represent, in their entirety and without reservation, the dark, pro-capitalist manifesto of syndicalism. The notion of a consensus between workers and capitalists of a shared interest between the working class and the owners of capital, of a common future for both the exploiter and the exploited, and of securing the livelihoods, welfare, and social rights of the working masses under the umbrella of capitalist rule is the vilest and most repulsive piece of mythology in human history. Workers across the globe must grasp that the trade unionist movement, throughout its entire shameful history, has lulled workers with these lies and mercenary distortions but not a single iota of the gains achieved through the struggles of the world’s workers has stemmed from the policies, planning, or role of trade unionism. Within the realm of his own trade-unionist delusions, Davoud Razavi clings to the fanciful belief that it was, in fact, this trade union movement or a collection of labour unions that brought about the modest levels of livelihood and social security enjoyed by workers in European countries. If the working masses in Europe or anywhere else in the world have not yet seen the very fabric of their lives completely unravelled by the pressures of hunger, poverty, homelessness, a lack of medicine, and other forms of deprivation, it is solely due to the wave of their continuous struggle and protest. With its powerful intensity, this wave first shatters the barrier of resistance erected by trade-union reformism; it then surges into the protected sanctuary of capitalist profit-making, compelling the custodians of these impotent, “miracle-less” unions to engage in bargaining with the capitalists and their state. Whatever remnants of progress still exist within the European labour movement are not owed to syndicalism; rather, they are the legacy of the most brilliant and glorious episodes of class struggle in history the Paris Commune, the First International, the October Revolution, and other such magnificent, epic events combined with the persistent, widespread, and potent struggles waged by the masses themselves over the past several centuries. Meanwhile, ensconced within a dark halo of his own illusions and distortions, Davoud Razavi unabashed and utterly shameless lays bare the true, raw essence of syndicalism. He asserts that the fundamental basis of his preferred approach is to forge a compromise between the exploited and the exploiter between the god-like power of capital and wage-slaves stripped of all rights and agency, and between the masses of workers and the owners of colossal capitalist trusts. But he insists that this practice, tradition, policy, and syndicalist role is paradoxically in the interest of the workers and serves to sustain the lives of the working masses! This is a blatant lie; for, contrary to the hollow claims propagated by the leaders of right-wing, reformist syndicalism, the function of these unions does not even extend to reducing the surplus labour extracted from the masses or improving their living conditions even in exchange for the abandonment of the working class’s anti-capitalist struggle. What, then, is the true role of these institutions? The struggle against capital has been an existential necessity for workers worldwide, throughout the entire history of their class. The working masses cannot afford to cease their struggle against capital, for any pause in the class struggle effectively cedes the field to capital, allowing the capitalist system to run rampant with ever-increasing brutality in its destruction of the workers’ livelihoods and the very conditions of their social existence.

The class struggle of the working masses even at the most rudimentary levels and with the most modest of expectations and demands inevitably exerts pressure on the rate of surplus value. More fundamentally, any leniency on the part of capitalists or capitalist states in swiftly and successfully containing these struggles risks undermining the very fabric of capital’s existence. Crushing the struggles of the working class is a vital, existential necessity for the survival of capital; this can be achieved in two ways: either through a bloodbath as practiced by the imperial (monarchical) and Islamic capitalist regimes in Iran or by permitting the emergence of specific civil and trade-union institutions that channel the anti-capitalist movement of the working class into the murky corridors of bargaining over the price of labour power. In their true essence, trade unions wherever they exist perform the same function as the army, the police, and other repressive apparatuses of capital elsewhere; they simply do so through their own distinct, ostensibly legitimate, peaceful, and quasi-clerical methods. The role of these institutions manifests in the context of the inevitable, structural class conflict inherent in wage-labour relations: the working masses engage in struggle to impose their immediate demands upon the operational processes of capital. Regarding the conditions of their labour, exploitation, and social existence, workers exert pressure upon the syndicates and unions or, in reality, those very civil institutions that enforce the capitalist order upon their own class. For long days and months, the unions deploying all their strength and the full extent of their bureaucratic apparatus strive to stifle this stirring of unrest. Naturally, the leaders of syndicalism fail in this endeavour. The reason is quite clear: a hungry stomach shatters the logic of capital, and the machinations of union bosses prove incapable of containing the defiant protests of starving wage-slaves. It is at this point that the next phase of the unions’ efforts and stratagems begins. Once again, they are exerting all their might to curtail the expectations of workers and moderate the scope of their demands. This phase drags on for some time; eventually after navigating all these detours and the gruelling, dark ordeals of subjugation to capital the union leaders, fulfilling their duty to bury the workers’ struggles, present themselves before the “sacred” altar of the owners of capital. There, they engage in collusion, negotiation, and compromise regarding the execution of this task. The entire mission of syndicalism and the trade union movement boils down to pursuing these very ends. Yet, articulating this reality naturally gives rise to a serious and significant question: if this is the sole function of unions, how have they managed to impose themselves upon the masses of workers and their movement for so many years? This question becomes even more complex when one considers that the working class in certain societies while submitting to the framework of trade-union reformism has not faced (and still does not face) the same level of brutal repression or the “bloodbaths” seen in many other nations. We have addressed this question repeatedly. Over a long period, the European bourgeoisie thanks to its massive share of the total surplus value generated by the international working class has possessed the means to pay for the labour power of workers in Scandinavia, Germany, France, England, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and even Portugal, Spain, and Italy at a higher rate than that of workers in Iran. This has provided unions with an effective weapon to suppress and dismantle the class struggle of the working masses, thereby serving the interests of capital. For all the reasons we have elaborated upon in numerous articles and extensive documentation, the Iranian bourgeoisie is unwilling to pay such a price for the labour power of the working class. In this context, a bloodbath serves as capital’s primary and ultimate weapon; in Europe, however, throughout the twentieth century, the bourgeoisie also wielded the weapon of compromise offering incremental wage increases to avert the threat of a class struggle against the wage-labour system. In this process, trade unions functioned as the vanguard forces of the capitalist order. The reality of this situation requires no elaborate discussion or complex argumentation. Regarding the true essence of the historical role of trade unions, any worker possessing even a rudimentary level of class consciousness anywhere in the world knows full well that, thanks to the existence of these unions and their interventions, global capital has, for over a century, succeeded in crushing the anti-capitalist movement of the working masses. As for the reasons behind the success of these unions and the role played by the substantial share of the massive surplus value (generated by the international working class) that the continental bourgeoisie allocated to them one need only look at current conditions and the events unfolding around us. Over the past few decades, the inherent and inevitable course of events within the capitalist mode of production has placed the global bourgeoisie including the European bourgeoisie in a position where they no longer view the continued existence of certain livelihood provisions, welfare benefits, or higher wage levels for workers on the continent as compatible with the requirements of maintaining wage slavery. Against this backdrop, and throughout these same decades, the decline of trade unions has been proclaimed far and wide. Twenty years ago, the Swedish national trade union confederation was one of the largest and most powerful labour organizations in Europe; driven by economic and social necessity on the one hand, and by a lack of future prospects, disillusionment, and the manipulative tactics of social democracy on the other, approximately 97% of the country’s entire workforce held membership within it. In just the last few years, this confederation has lost about 500,000 members a significant portion of its former two-million-strong base and its process of disintegration and collapse is accelerating. This same trend has unfolded in other European countries as well, albeit at varying speeds. Syndicalists including members of the board of the United Bus Company Workers’ Union would do well to take careful note of these developments. Over the last two decades, the working masses in Europe have needed more than ever unity, organization, and the consolidation of their militant ranks, if only to defend their existing conditions and current wage levels. But on a massive scale, they have abandoned the unions. Why? Simply because the unions, in the very fabric of their existence, have served and continue to serve as instruments for imposing the interests of capital accumulation upon the working class. Now that the continent’s capitalist class seeks to exert an increasingly crushing and devastating pressure on the living standards and social welfare of European workers, the unions eager to please and fully submissive are busy facilitating the unquestioning implementation of capital’s agenda. Just as they fulfilled capital’s expectations in the past, the unions are currently restructuring themselves to carry out those same missions today. The real difference between the unions of the past and those of the present merely reflects the evolution in the methods the bourgeoisie employs to confront the labour movement. Until a few decades ago, capital preferred to reach an accommodation that ensured the bare minimum subsistence for workers, rather than risk the eruption of an anti-capitalist movement. In this context, it viewed the traditional form of trade unions as an effective mechanism for containing the labour movement. Today, however, this arrangement no longer serves the interests of capital. Firstly, entangled in the complexities of its own inherent and unruly contradictions, capital now perceives the systematic destruction of the working masses’ livelihoods as an existential necessity. Secondly, it views the gains achieved by the trade union movement over several decades which have effectively gutted the working class’s anti-capitalist struggle as a “safe haven,” at least in the short term, shielding it from the organized and ideologically driven onslaught of the European labour movement. Elsewhere in his remarks, Davoud Razavi engages in childish wishful thinking regarding the maturation, consolidation, and potential success of a right-wing, reformist trade unionism in Iran. He expresses hope that, through the efforts of syndicalists like himself, this approach will gain strength day by day; he interprets the existence of the “Vahed” (United) Company Syndicate along with the nominal, paper-only emergence of other syndicalist circles as signs of the dawn and flourishing of right-wing reformism within the Iranian labour movement. The reality is that what this board member of the Vahed Syndicate proposes and aspires to is, in fact, a shared dream and expectation held by a remarkably broad spectrum of political forces ranging from the anti-labour factions within the Islamic capitalist state to those pseudo-leftist sects that masquerade as “left” parties and groups. Davoud Razavi is not alone in this fantasy. Each of the various segments within this broad spectrum for different reasons and in its own particular way awaits the rise of this lucky star, the emergence of this syndicalist “Moon of Nakhshab ” (as a miracle). Individuals like Davoud Razavi dream night after night of establishing an expansive, bureaucratic union apparatus modelled after the European labour unions of the 20th century. They envision themselves ascending to the throne of bureaucratic power, sitting shoulder-to-shoulder with capitalists and the statesmen of capital, and through this arrangement inextricably and favourably intertwining their own future with that of the capitalists and the rulers of the capitalist system. The proponents of the reactionary, anti-labour “2nd of Khordad” movement who have flourished and expanded deep within the Islamic state of capital view their specific, tailor-made brand of syndicalism as a potent weapon in their struggles against rival factions within the political power structure of capital. It is for this very reason that their leaders have long been seen posing for photographs with figures like Razavi, Osanloo, and Madadi. It is within this same context that Mr. Abdi has reached out to Messrs. Razavi and Madadi. Furthermore, certain right-wing syndicalists schooled in the SAVAK-created unions of the past along with their associates, anticipate that should a syndicalist approach gain traction and powerful, Western-style labour unions emerge, they too might secure a place for themselves within the hallowed halls of capital even if it means clinging to the coattails of the likes of Osanloo and Razavi. The Tudehists (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tudeh_Party_of_Iran) and the “Majority” faction (Organization of Iranian People’s Fada’i (Majority)) who have historically championed a degenerate, syndicalist reformism have viewed any success of this approach as a stepping stone to co-opt the struggles of the working masses and pave the way for securing a position within the capitalist state apparatus. In their desperate pursuit of this goal, they have stopped at nothing, committing all manner of crimes. Furthermore, a multitude of other leftist parties and groups driven by the inherent logic of trade unionism and its bureaucracy regard unions solely as an effective conveyor belt for ascending to political power, allowing them to seize the reins of state-managed planning within the capitalist order of production, politics, and society. Intoxicated by the scent of what they perceive as a lucrative opportunity, they are one after another hastily removing portraits of Marx from the facades of their own “shops” and replacing them with the image of Mansour Osanloo (a figure associated with the “Second of Khordad” reformist movement). This recent development is, in fact, a welcome change; it was a truly egregious affront to have the image of a man like Marx exploited as a mere prop for the petty enterprises of these opportunists who shift their allegiances with the prevailing winds.

In short, what Davoud Razavi aspires to represents the common thread running through the fantasies of this entire chaotic spectrum a spectrum rife with conflict and strife. This is a reality that, in all its ugliness and repulsiveness, has been laid completely bare before everyone’s eyes over the past few years. The scope of these efforts has by no means been confined to the informal, unwritten “unity of action” among these various currents and groups. Democratic and conservative senators, the U.S. President, Condoleezza Rice, and various American bourgeois officials along with the occupants of the Élysée Palace, the capitalist rulers of Britain, the International Labour Organization (ILO), the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC), the International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITF), and a host of other organizations all masquerading as “labour unions” while serving as mercenaries for global capital have each intervened for their own specific ends. They have all lent their support to the establishment of a fraudulent, “miracle-less” shrine to syndicalism in Iran. A tremendous uproar has been orchestrated in this regard, and mountains of lies have been piled up. Union leaders, engaging in vile demagoguery, have sought to construct this edifice of deception a form of syndicalism tailored to the tastes of global capital within the heart of the Iranian labour movement, all while falsely stamping it with the seal of “solidarity with labour activists.” Meanwhile, reformist and syndicalist circles both left and right based abroad have done everything in their power to foster illusions among Iranian workers by weaving these elaborate schemes. Indeed, all these actions have been taken; But Mr. Davoud Razavi and his associates must realize that right-wing trade union reformism within Iranian society and the Iranian labour movement stands absolutely no chance of achieving any level of success in any arena. We have already discussed this point extensively. Nevertheless, as long as trade unionism persists in its attempts to deceive the Iranian working masses, revisiting these arguments remains both urgent and necessary. Iranian capitalism is an integral part of global capitalism. Within this system, the following elements are inseparable components indeed, the inevitable and mandatory conditions of the process of capital reproduction: the increasingly intense, horrific, and brutal exploitation of labour power; the reduction of the price of labour power to an abysmal, near-zero level; the total deprivation of the working masses regarding welfare facilities and basic necessities of life; the creation of a “bloodbath” within the labour movement, involving the suppression of any sign of protest or dissent from the working class; the denial of even minimal access to healthcare and education; and the imposition of poverty, hunger, homelessness in short, every conceivable form of wretchedness upon the working class. The position of Iranian capitalism within the global capitalist division of labour has inextricably linked the processes of value-augmentation, reproduction, and the self-expansion of social capital to a web of constraints. Consequently, as long as capitalist rule prevails and specifically as long as the buying and selling of labour power remains the dominant relation the Iranian working class has no prospect of attaining a decent, humane standard of living or even a basic level of social welfare. The surplus value generated by the exploitation of the entire international working class is distributed among global capitals in accordance with the inherent laws governing the allocation of capitalist profit. Each segment of global capital secures its specific share of this total surplus value, determined by the interplay of various capitalist factors. The objective logic of the existing capitalist division of labour dictates that the brutal exploitation of the working masses in Iran and in similarly situated nations must serve a dual purpose: beyond satisfying the requirements for the reproduction and ever-greater self-expansion of capital invested within the domestic market, this exploitation must also in a massive, overwhelming flow feed into the global capitalist system, meeting the demand to boost the rate of profit for other, colossal, and gargantuan segments of global capital. This is the compulsion of the capitalist system and the inevitable requirement of the division of labour inherent to capital on a global scale. Under the suffocating, lethal grip of this system, the Iranian working class faces no prospect whatsoever of achieving a decent, humane standard of living. In the current historical context at this specific phase in the historical decline of capitalism this situation has assumed even more horrific and terrifying dimensions, a trend destined to intensify further. A fundamental, immutable, and uncontrollable feature of capital in its present state is the unprecedented, rapid surge in the average organic composition of capital on a global scale. This phenomenon has profoundly expanded the core origins and true sources of crises deep within the very life of capital. Consequently, every attempt by the capitalist system to counter these crises and to secure the conditions for its continued survival and reproduction has inevitably led to the orchestration of the most brutal, criminal, and horrific assaults against the last vestiges of the working masses’ livelihoods, across the globe and nowhere more acutely than in societies like Iran. In such a society situated within a phase of profound historical decay of the anti-human capitalist system the role of syndicalism is abundantly clear. Right-wing, reformist syndicalism will not only fail to bring about any improvement whatsoever in any aspect of the working class’s life; rather, it will function precisely like the current capitalist state’s repressive apparatus the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), the regular army, and the police or, indeed, like the SAVAK of the past. While in Western societies during the 20th century, syndicalism by facilitating the betrayal and decimation of the anti-wage-labour movement was able to leverage the tacit agreements between massive Western industrial and financial monopolies and the meagre, subsistence-level wages of European workers to sustain its own manoeuvres, no such possibility exists in Iran. Here, syndicalism will effectively become an extension of the intelligence services, the SAVAK, the army, and the IRGC; it will don the guise of “workers” and “labour activists” only to strive to impose the full spectrum of capital’s crimes, brutalities, and malevolence upon the working masses. The functions previously carried out by the “Workers’ House” (Khaneh Kargar), the “Islamic Labor Councils,” and the SAVAK will simply be continued by these syndicates and unions. The “Second of Khordad” faction, American senators, figures like Bush and Rice, global labour unions, and their ilk when they advocate for a syndicalist approach in Iran know full well what they are doing. They seek to engineer this artifice a “miracle” steeped in trickery and deception to serve two purposes: first, to provide an immediate guarantee for containing any anti-capitalist or anti-wage-labour uprising among the Iranian working masses; and second, to gain leverage within the ongoing internal disputes of the international bourgeoisie, thereby securing a more dominant position at the negotiating table and in their routine dealings with the Islamic bourgeois state of Iran. As for other political currents, we have already explained their aims and objectives. But the fundamental the truly fundamental question remains: why would the Iranian working class ever accept this monstrous incubus an instrument for the repression and the imposition of capitalist force and, by what twisted logic, come to view it as a vehicle for its own self-expression? The very notion is so banal, so utterly foolish and absurd, that only a reactionary syndicalist or a handful of sectarians, self-serving political hucksters could possibly believe in it.

Davoud Razavi, along with the entire spectrum of forces and circles mentioned earlier, must realize and take this reality firmly to heart that syndicalism will never take root in Iran. The masses of the Iranian working class have no path before them other than to struggle against capital and to abolish the entire capitalist system. Razavi and all the elements within that spectrum must understand that they will gain absolutely nothing from their illusory, unattainable goals. Nationwide, council-based, anti-capitalist organization is the sole solution for the working-class masses. Every extra cent in wages and every marginal improvement in the living conditions of the Iranian working class depend upon launching an offensive against the operational logic of capital and exercising organized, council-based power against the very foundations of capitalism’s existence. The Iranian working-class masses will either take this course in which case they will triumph or they will fail to do so in which case they will be destroyed. There is no other way. In the former scenario, a nationwide, council-based, anti-capitalist movement of the working class will sweep away syndicalism, factionalism, and all reformist approaches whether of the right or the left like mere debris in a flood, burying them deep within the sedimentary layers of human history as fossils. Before concluding this discussion, we find it necessary to point out one further matter. For a long time, the rabid dictatorship of capital in Iran has served to lend a veneer of legitimacy to even the slightest reformist manoeuvre even those initiated by factions of the opposition operating from within the state apparatus of capital. Under the shield of this dictatorship, everything from anti-labour agendas hostile to the most basic livelihood rights of the working masses to syndicalist reformism within or on the fringes of the labour movement, has managed to cloak itself in the guise of the oppressed, the seeker of justice, the champion of freedom, the militant fighter, and the defender of workers’ rights. Numerous elements, circles, and currents have presented themselves as allies of the workers’ struggles and the protests of the labouring masses, solely on the basis that they are supposedly targets of the wrath of the more dominant factions of the bourgeoisie. These circles ranging from the right to the left have leveraged their position as an “opposition” to sow illusions among the workers, using these very illusions as a springboard to secure political standing or to leap into the state apparatus of capital. In other words, thanks to this naked and rabid dictatorship, the capitalist system has not merely suppressed the struggles of the working masses; it has also paved the way for various bourgeois opposition groups, as well as reformist and syndicalist currents, to propagate illusions among the workers. It is under the shadow of this dictatorship and the naked coercion of capital that individuals like Davoud Razavi present themselves not merely as fighters defending workers’ rights, but as combatants “in the thick of the fray” and indeed, *very* deep in the thick of it! while simultaneously acting as if the workers, along with all the conscious, committed, and diligent activists of the working class’s anti-capitalist movement, owe *them* something. Regardless, Davoud Razavi should know that his posturing as a victim and his invocation of the imprisonment of figures like Osanloo will not receive any politically conscious worker. The fact that the rabid bourgeois state imprisons even individuals like Davoud Razavi demonstrates only one thing: the capitalist system in Iran cannot tolerate even right-wing, syndicalist reformism just as it cannot tolerate the squabbles of figures like Akbar Ganji, Aghajari, Montazeri, and other henchmen of its own class or, to be more precise, those who belong to the inner circle of its own political power. Davoud Razavi is free to consider himself a fighter “in the thick of the fray” of syndicalism even if he is buried kilometres deep within that pit. The crux of the matter is that Mr. Razavi’s “pit” is a hole dug within the framework of formal or informal agreements between right-wing syndicalist reformists and segments of the bourgeoisie specifically to bury the working class’s anti-wage-labour and anti-capitalist movement. This pit is not a site for workers’ struggle against capitalism; rather, it is a stall where the Iranian labour movement is sold off to capital. Anti-capitalist activists will not only steer clear of this pit but will also use all their strength and capacity to prevent any worker from falling into it.

September 2008

Continue Reading

Previous: Why a nationwide, anti-capitalist organization?

Related Stories

Why a nationwide, anti-capitalist organization?
74 min read
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism

Why a nationwide, anti-capitalist organization?

October 15, 2026
A labour organization independent of the state! Dissolved within the order of capital
20 min read
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism

A labour organization independent of the state! Dissolved within the order of capital

October 14, 2026
Bourgeois Elections and the Swedish Labor Movement
10 min read
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism

Bourgeois Elections and the Swedish Labor Movement

October 13, 2026

Recent Posts

  • Civil Movements: A Carnival of Discontent in the Mill of Capitalist Survival
  • A war between states is their joint war against the workers
  • The most terrifying dilemma in history: the eradication of capitalism or the destruction of humanity
  • Davoud Razavi and the Struggle in the Arena!
  • Why a nationwide, anti-capitalist organization?

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

Archives

  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • September 2025
  • August 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • July 2024
  • April 2024
  • January 2024
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022

Menu

  • Against environmental degradation and destruction of nature
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism
  • Capital and child labor
  • Capital and crisis
  • capital and domestic work
  • Capitalism and forcible poverty
  • Communism Abolition of Wage Labor and Leninist Militant Reformism
  • Lesson and achievements of the world labour movement
  • Rereading Marx's Capital
  • Socialism, economics and politics
  • Struggle against oppression and gender discrimination
  • The class battle against exploitation and plunder of the products of labor
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour
  • Views and reviews

You may have missed

Civil Movements: A Carnival of Discontent in the Mill of Capitalist Survival
14 min read
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour

Civil Movements: A Carnival of Discontent in the Mill of Capitalist Survival

October 28, 2026
A war between states is their joint war against the workers
6 min read
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour

A war between states is their joint war against the workers

October 23, 2026
The most terrifying dilemma in history: the eradication of capitalism or the destruction of humanity
29 min read
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour

The most terrifying dilemma in history: the eradication of capitalism or the destruction of humanity

October 19, 2026
Davoud Razavi and the Struggle in the Arena!
30 min read
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism

Davoud Razavi and the Struggle in the Arena!

October 16, 2026
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism
  • Capital and crisis
  • Capital and domestic work !
  • Capital and exploitation of children
  • Struggle against oppression and gender discrimination
  • Capitalism and forcible poverty
  • Against environmental degradation and destruction of nature !
  • Lesson and achievements of the world labour movement
  • Views and reviews
  • The class battle against exploitation and plunder of products of labor
  • workersagainstagainstwagelaboursystem
  • The movement of abolition wage-labour
  • Anti-capitalist critique of reformism
  • Capital and crisis
  • Capital and domestic work !
  • Capital and exploitation of children
  • Struggle against oppression and gender discrimination
  • Capitalism and forcible poverty
  • Against environmental degradation and destruction of nature !
  • Lesson and achievements of the world labour movement
  • Views and reviews
  • The class battle against exploitation and plunder of products of labor
  • workersagainstagainstwagelaboursystem
Copyright © All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.