Nasser Paydar Part Seven of Right-wing unionist reformism
On Sunday, September 17 (September 2006), the Swedish working class will head to the polls in an atmosphere of great freedom and equality, and free from police or military pressure to decide which faction of the bourgeoisie will, over the next four years, plan and impose the exploitation, disenfranchisement, oppression, and the steady erosion of their livelihood at the hands of capital. This is the only down-to-earth interpretation of parliamentarism and the only real outcome of workers’ participation in these elections. The bourgeois right-wing coalition now in the final moments of waiting to assume a dominant role in the state apparatus has long since declared that it will show no mercy toward the citizens’ means of subsistence and welfare; it will bury the Swedish working class’s share of the crumbling legacy of global labour struggles. The Swedish worker must settle for the standard of living of their Chinese and Singaporean counterparts; otherwise, they will be replaced by the virtually free labour of hungry workers from Asia, Africa, and Eastern Europe. The practice of hiring labour is being supplanted by the unconditional buying and selling of human beings a fossilized relic of the past. The right-wing coalition has declared its intention to slash employment and income taxes in the interest of capital. Through the privatization of healthcare, education, childcare, elderly care, and everything else, it aims to put an end to the very concept of social welfare. It seeks to maximize competition among the sellers of labour to drive down wage levels and replace existing immigration policies with the importation of virtually free labour. These are the broad outlines of the right-wing coalition’s promises. The left-wing coalition has held power for many years; during this time, it has implemented albeit with varying degrees of rationality or appeasement the very measures now promised by the right-wing parties, and consequently, it has nothing new to offer. A significant portion of Swedish workers is aware of these issues; this gives rise to two fundamental questions. The first question is why workers continue to head to the polls in such large numbers; the second answer which is more important and vital is: “If they abandon this, what alternative is there?” If they forgo the elections, to what course of action should they turn?
The answer to the first question must be sought in the track record of social democracy, the entire spectrum of left-wing reformism, and the existence of labour unions. For a full century, this political current despite its internal differences has acted with unity, homogeneity, and a single voice: they have erased any horizon of struggle against capitalism from the working class’s worldview and lived reality. In executing this dark historical scenario, numerous left-wing factions whether within or outside the corridors of political power have played the same role as right-wing, syndicalist reformism. The practical translation of their theorizing, policies, and strategic proposals has been the notion that workers should base their efforts on achieving a “better life”!! while remaining under the yoke of the wage-slavery system. Together and in lockstep, they have instilled in the minds of workers the idea that syndicalism and parliamentarism are the arenas for improving life!! within this system; consequently, the Swedish working class influenced by their directives and visions has never even conceived of a horizon distinct from that of capital, nor a life other than one lived under the dominion of capitalism. Even the most radical among them posing every four years as ardent champions of freedom and working-class socialism!!! have set up their platforms of supplication, hoping to use workers’ votes to join the ranks of capital’s anti-human rulers and become partners in the bourgeoisie’s schemes of exploitation and the stripping of workers’ rights.
Throughout the past century, social democracy and nationwide labour organizations have striven to surgically excise the working class’s oppositional consciousness regarding capital root and branch and replace it with a mindset and evaluative framework aligned with the interests of capital. They cultivated a deadly poison in every fibre of the workers’ minds: the notion that every single dinar of improvement in their lives is inextricably linked to an increase of hundreds of dinars in capital’s profits! With brazen dishonesty, they foisted the wretchedness and squalor of Russian state capitalism upon the workers, labelling it “communism,” and used this hatred for a counterfeit version of communism to bind the working masses in subservience to the relations of wage labour.
Under the pressure of all-encompassing illusions propagated by both right-wing and left-wing reformism and while fixated on the terrifying Specter of the Eastern Bloc the Swedish working class submitted to the bourgeoisie and the notion of capitalism’s permanence to such an extent that it lost sight of the actual roots of the disparities in living standards and welfare separating it from workers elsewhere in the world. The Swedish worker forgot that the subsistence-level livelihood enjoyed in comparison to Asian counterparts was neither a fruit of social democracy, nor a gift from the trade union movement, nor a sign of the Scandinavian bourgeoisie’s superior benevolence, but rather the product of a different source entirely. The Swedish worker forgot that this minimum standard of living and welfare was a remnant of the concessions global capital once granted to a segment of the world’s workers compelled by the formidable power of the European labour movement, the dread of a repeat of the Communards’ actions, and the fear of another “October” revolution. By seizing upon these minimal provisions without reflecting on their underlying rationale and becoming thoroughly ensnared in the web of illusions spun by social democracy, trade unionism, and pseudo-left reformism the Swedish working class allowed the struggle against the very foundations of capitalism, and the fight for its abolition, to fade into increasing insignificance.
Indeed, for all these reasons and despite witnessing a rapid decline in their standard of living and social welfare over the past two decades the Swedish labour movement finds itself in a position of acute confrontation with capitalism. Many workers realize that neither parliamentarism nor syndicalism will yield them any real gains. The carcass of parliamentarism is more putrid than ever; even global capital, in orchestrating its savagery against the world’s workers, has bypassed these institutions. Throughout the past year, we have repeatedly seen that the management of Sweden’s political, judicial, domestic, and foreign affairs was orchestrated not by the country’s bourgeois parliament, but by the bellicose enforcers of capital in the White House. Swedish media have morphed into a subservient branch of the “Wall Street” media; the situation is so glaring that ordinary people quip: “What are elections for? We have the US government!” much like millions across the globe who mockingly cry out: “What is the UN? The US rulers are the ones in charge!” All of this is reality, and a vast number of Swedish workers are well aware of it; but for the very reasons mentioned earlier, they cling to parliamentarism, wondering: “If we let go of this, what is there to take its place?”!! And it is precisely here that we must turn to the second question. What, indeed, is to be done?
The answer to this question is both simple and exceedingly complex. It is simple in the sense that the status quo is not the end of the world. Capitalism did not always exist, and it certainly will not endure forever. The scope of our power as workers is not confined to the boundaries of labour unions; on the contrary, it truly takes flight beyond that hallowed sanctuary. It is not supernatural forces or the blind determinism of history that have shaped human existence, but rather class struggle. It is by no means ordained that the extent of our livelihood, social welfare, and human rights must be sought within the benevolence of a Fredrik Reinfeldt or the magnanimity of a Göran Persson! Nor is it a historical decree that the fruits of our labour and toil should be transformed into capital in the hands of the owners of Ericsson, Volvo, and IKEA across the globe, while we wait for a pittance barely enough for bread or for medical care to bubble up from the cauldron of a right-left coalition’s charity. Is it preordained that everything we and successive generations of our class have created must be transmuted into capital a god-like power that dominates us? The answer is simple: everything is subject to change. The path to change is also entirely clear. Class struggle is and remains the sole locomotive driving change in the objective reality of any historical era. We are under no compulsion to cast our votes for a right-left coalition, thereby effectively nullifying our agency, freedom, and power to influence the world. Nor does any form of determinism bind us to the necessity of relying on trade unions. Instead, we can organize a genuinely effective struggle against the capitalist system. We must abandon the servile, defeatist belief that the system of wage slavery is eternal. We must cast aside the rusted, worn-out, and futile strategies used to confront the status quo. Resorting to parliaments, national unions, and institutions that uphold the capitalist order serves no purpose other than tightening the bourgeoisie’s noose ever more ruthlessly around our own necks. Why should capitalists, the right-left coalition of capital, or union leaders decide our livelihoods and the fate of our work and lives? We shall enter the arena of struggle ourselves. Instead of pinning our hopes on the empty promises of right-wing and left-wing bourgeois parties, we will draft our own charter of fundamental demands. We all unequivocally regard a prosperous standard of living complete with free healthcare, medical care, medication, and education for all as our inalienable right. Our children have every right to free childcare. Our elderly and disabled must have access to the best possible care facilities, entirely free of charge. We have the right to free housing. In the wake of the October Revolution, while declaring the exploitation of labour to be the antithesis of citizenship rights, our comrades-in-struggle loudly proclaimed to all people across the globe those oppressed and exploited by the evils of capital that should they make their way to the land of the October Revolution, they would enjoy full citizenship rights. We, too, declare to all those suffering under exploitation, dictatorship, warmongering, and the crimes of capitalism that our society belongs to them all. The fruits of our annual labour and production along with everything we and our working-class forebears have created to date are more than sufficient to provide for all these needs, and a hundred times over, in the best possible way. The net profit of just 90 Swedish monopolies this year has exceeded the total cost of our annual livelihood and social welfare. If we were to add the net profits of hundreds of other industrial and financial institutions, the figure would skyrocket. We view phenomena such as social assistance, unemployment benefits, and the like as an affront to our human dignity. We are the creators of all existing wealth, capital, and resources. Access to the highest standards of living, welfare, and social amenities is the right of every single one of us regardless of employment status, gender, age, place of birth, skin colour, race, or any other factor. We regard the attainment of all this as our inalienable right. There is nothing more degrading than sacrificing our entire human existence offering it up as fuel for the cauldron of “charity” dispensed by the right-left coalition of the bourgeois parliament merely to secure a pittance of these fundamental rights.
What we have outlined is the straightforward aspect of the answer. The challenging part lies in the fact that, to realize these expectations in practice to fight against capitalism and compel capitalists and their state to accept these demands we must unite and organize in a new way. We must launch a powerful, anti-capitalist council movement. We must organize councils upon the ruins of trade unions and replace the latter with a nationwide council organization. This task is certainly not easy, yet it is undoubtedly achievable. We must start somewhere. The process of advancing this struggle can begin by articulating these very demands and organizing ourselves into councils around them. Instead of sitting through Reinfeldt’s hateful rhetoric, listening to Persson’s insipid, banal, and deceitful promises, or agonizing over whether to entrust our fate to a right-wing or left-wing coalition, let us in every workplace, production site, and surrounding neighbourhood engage in dialogue and organize against the status quo, rallying around a charter of fundamental anti-capitalist rights and a vision of dismantling this system entirely. Instead of pinning our hopes on the union and the parliament of capital, let us organize the council-based power of the masses and bring it into the arena. Let us not dig our own graves with our own hands; rather, let us use that energy as mortar to build our own power and to wield our class strength against capital. Bourgeois representatives from right to left seek to use our votes to impose upon us the order of capitalist exploitation and barbarism. The day after the parliamentary elections, we will be reduced to nothing; if we wish to be a force to be reckoned with, we must unite around our demands and armed with these demands and a vision of abolishing capitalism stand united against the entire bourgeoisie and the system of wage slavery. Every successful step along this path represents a building block in expanding our struggles, strengthening our organization, and exerting greater power to more effectively force further concessions from the bourgeoisie marking a step forward toward dismantling the system of wage slavery.